Almost every fossil shark tooth found around Charleston comes from one of six sharks: sand tiger, mako, tiger, hemipristis (the snaggletooth), megalodon, and megalodon's older relative Otodus angustidens. I read four things together: size, serrations, root shape and color. Lean on just one and a mako starts to look like a sand tiger. Below are the six sharks, the fossils people mistake for teeth, where the teeth come from, and the line that decides whether you can keep what you find.
Half the fun of a hunt out here is working out what you just picked up. The Lowcountry is a forgiving place to learn, because six sharks account for almost everything that washes up on our beaches and each one leaves a tell. Where people go wrong is naming a tooth from one feature. One feature is never enough.
Read four things, and read them together
Size, serrations, root shape, color. I check them in that order on every tooth somebody holds up on the beach, and once you've done it a dozen times it takes a few seconds. Serrations alone will hand you three different sharks. Color tells you almost nothing about the species and a fair amount about how the tooth was buried. Size is the fastest filter and the easiest to misjudge, because a small broad triangle and a large slender blade come from different animals, not from one animal at two ages.
Go in that order and most teeth sort themselves out on the spot. Color comes last for me, because on its own it misleads more than it helps.
Sand tiger: the small needle with side cusps
- Shape and cusps: slender and smooth, with a tall narrow crown and a tiny side point at the base on each side, which is the giveaway
- Serrations and root: no serrations at all, on a forked and surprisingly delicate root that is the part most likely to break
- Size: small, mostly under three-quarters of an inch
Start here. Sand tiger teeth are ones hunters often find on Lowcountry beaches, and if you're picking up lots of small, smooth, needle-shaped teeth with little side points, you have sand tiger and you're on the right kind of ground. Nobody puts a sand tiger tooth on the mantel. When a stretch of beach starts giving them up, though, we stay on it.
Mako: the smooth blade
- Shape: narrow, curved and blade-like, with a slight S-curve when you look at it edge-on
- Serrations and root: clean, glossy edges with no serrations, on a deeply forked root with a wide arch between the lobes
- Size: up to about two inches
A smooth, glossy, slightly S-curved tooth with no serrations is almost always a mako. The mix-up is with sand tiger. Look at the base of the crown: sand tiger has the little side cusps and mako doesn't.
Tiger shark: the cockscomb
- Shape: curved sideways with a deep notch on one side, like a rooster's comb
- Serrations and root: heavy serrations that are themselves serrated, on a short, broad root
- Size: mostly under an inch
See one and you'll spot every one after it. Nothing else on this coast has that sideways hook, and if you turn the tooth against the light you can see the double serration with the naked eye.
Hemipristis: the snaggletooth
- Shape: hooked and lopsided, with coarse serrations along the upper edge only
- Color and root: orange, amber or warm grey, on a broad, arched root
- Size: up to about an inch and a half
This is the one collectors want. Hemipristis serra turns up right through the Charleston-area deposits, and a clean one with its color intact makes most people's day out here. The coarse serrations run along one edge and then stop, which is the quickest way to separate it from a small tiger shark tooth.
Megalodon, and the older shark people mistake for it
Megalodon is the broad triangle. Fine, even serrations run down both edges, the root is thick and heavy, and there's a darker chevron band between crown and root that collectors call the bourlette. Sizes run from an inch to over seven, and anything past three inches is a real prize. Most beach finds around here are small, worn or partial. The big complete ones mostly come out of the rivers, which is a different activity with its own rule (more on that below).
Charleston also produces Otodus angustidens, the megatoothed shark that came before megalodon, and at a glance it reads as a smallish meg. Look at the shoulders of the crown. Angustidens carries a pointed cusplet on each side of the main blade, and its serrations are coarser. Megalodon lost those cusplets. So a broad triangular tooth with side cusplets is an angustidens, the older of the two by a wide margin. They're common enough in the Oligocene beds under us that a 2021 study by researchers at the College of Charleston and the Charleston Museum concluded the area was a nursery for young angustidens, because the collections they studied were dominated by small teeth from juveniles and newborns.
| Find | Typical size | Serrations | Root | Color | How common |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sand tiger | Under 0.75 in | None; tiny side cusps | Forked, delicate | Grey to tan | Common |
| Mako | Up to 2 in | None; smooth glossy edge | Deeply forked | Grey, blue-black | Common |
| Tiger shark | Under 1 in | Heavy, doubly serrated | Short, broad | Brown to black | Common |
| Hemipristis | Up to 1.5 in | Coarse, upper edge only | Broad, arched | Orange, amber, grey | Uncommon, prized |
| Megalodon | 1 to 7+ in | Fine, even, both edges | Thick, heavy, bourlette | Grey, tan, black | Small: common. Large: rare |
| Otodus angustidens | 1 to 4 in | Coarse, with side cusplets | Heavy, squared | Grey to brown | Uncommon |
| Ray dental plate | Varies | None; ridged surface | No root at all | Purple-grey | Common; often misidentified |

Our crew stays on the island with you, and checking finds as you go is a big part of that job. One guest put it this way:
"Bailey and Ricky are fantastic! We were on a girl's trip and wanted to get shark teeth. Bailey stayed with us on the island the entire trip and made sure we were competent in identifying the teeth. We can't recommend LowCountry enough!"— Sandra King, Google review
Not a tooth? Here's what else you're picking up
- Ray dental plates: purple-grey, ridged slabs of pavement the ray used to crush oysters and clams. No root and no point. It's a frequent mix-up.
- Fossil bone and vertebrae: porous and light, with vertebrae shaped like small barrels and dished at each end
- Drum fish otoliths, the smooth white ear bones locals call lucky stones
- Coral, petrified wood and phosphate nodules, all dark and rounded and easy to pocket by mistake
Where these teeth come from
The rock under this part of the coast is older than most visitors expect, and there's more than one layer of it. The two units that matter most sit beneath the Charleston area, and both are Oligocene: the Ashley Formation, roughly 27 to 29 million years old, and the Chandler Bridge Formation above it, about 23 to 25 million years old.
Younger material sits on top. There are early Miocene sands, Pliocene limestone, and Pleistocene deposits laid down when sea level stood somewhere else. What lands on a beach or a sandbar is a shuffled deck drawn from all of them, which is why an Oligocene angustidens and a much younger megalodon can come out of the same handful of shell hash. Nothing sorts them for you. It's also why you can't date a loose tooth by eye. You can only say what it is.

Why they're black, and what the color can't tell you
The dark color isn't the original tooth. Over a long burial the enameloid and dentine take up minerals from the sediment around them, and the tooth comes out the color of the mud it sat in: black, grey, brown, or for a lot of hemipristis, a warm orange. A tooth from a phosphate-rich bed comes out darker than one from clean sand of the same age. So color is a record of the sediment. It won't give you the species or the age.
Bright white teeth are modern. They rarely last long enough on this coast to be worth picking up.

How long megalodon has been gone
The species is long gone, and the date has moved. A 2019 study that re-examined every late record and threw out the reworked ones concluded megalodon was extinct by about 3.6 million years ago, roughly a million years earlier than the figure older articles still quote. Whatever meg you pick up on a Lowcountry beach, that shark had been dead a very long time before anyone was here to look for it.
What the law says about keeping what you find
The line here is physical, so it's worth being exact. South Carolina's jurisdiction over state waters starts at the mean low water mark. Picking a tooth off the beach above that line is ordinary beachcombing, and that's where we hunt. Collecting below it, in a creek, a river or off any bottom the state holds title to, takes a Hobby License issued by the South Carolina Institute of Archaeology and Anthropology at the University of South Carolina.
- It's cheap: $5 for six months in state or $10 out of state, and $18 or $36 for two years.
- It allows hand collection only. No shovels, rakes, scoops or screens, no moving sediment to expose anything (even on a dry riverbank in a drought), and magnet fishing is banned outright.
- Fossil finds are reported to the South Carolina State Museum every quarter, and title passes to you within 60 days of each report.
One more thing worth knowing. According to the Institute's own FAQ, South Carolina is the only state that specifically permits recreational collecting of artifacts and fossils from submerged sites.
If you're walking the beach and pocketing what the tide left, you're fine. Working a riverbed or the bottom of a tidal creek is the point where you get the license first.
Still not sure? Bring it to the boat
Identifying finds is half the day on our Morris Island hunts, and nothing beats putting a tooth in the hand of someone who does this for a living. The shared hunt runs 4 hours at $125 per person from Shem Creek. Departure times follow the tide, so check the booking calendar for your date. We provide the gear and you keep everything you find.
If you're not out with us, photograph the tooth on a plain background with a coin beside it for scale. Get both faces and the edge-on view. The root and the profile are where the answer is.
Pricing, BYOB rules, weather policy, and departure details are all on our FAQ page — or call (843) 874-8555.
Frequently Asked
How can you tell a megalodon tooth from other shark teeth?
Look at the size and the root first. Megalodon teeth are broad triangles with fine, even serrations along both edges and a thick, heavy root, with a darker chevron band called the bourlette between crown and root. Anything over three inches is almost certainly a meg. Then check the shoulders of the crown: if there are small side cusplets, it's Otodus angustidens.
What does a sand tiger shark tooth look like?
Slender, smooth and needle-like, with tiny cusps at the base of the crown and a forked, delicate root. Most are under three-quarters of an inch, and those side cusps are what separate a sand tiger from a mako.
Why are fossil shark teeth black or grey?
Minerals from the surrounding sediment replace the original material during a long burial, so the tooth ends up the color of the mud it sat in. The color reflects the deposit, not the species or the age. Bright white teeth are modern and rarely survive on the beach.
What is a snaggletooth?
The common name for Hemipristis, a shark whose hooked teeth carry coarse serrations along the upper edge only and come out orange, amber or grey. They're among the most sought-after finds on this coast.
I found a flat, ridged purple plate. What is it?
A ray dental plate. Rays used these pavement-like plates to crush oysters and clams. They have no root and no point, they're common in the Lowcountry, and they're the fossil most often mistaken for a tooth.
How old are the shark teeth found near Charleston?
Older than a lot of people assume. The main fossil-bearing units under the Charleston area are Oligocene: the Ashley Formation at roughly 27 to 29 million years and the Chandler Bridge Formation at about 23 to 25 million years. Younger Miocene, Pliocene and Pleistocene material is mixed in above them, and a single beach find can come from any of them.
Do you need a license to collect shark teeth in South Carolina?
Not on the beach. Surface collecting above the mean low water mark needs no license. Below that line, including rivers and creeks, you need a Hobby License from the South Carolina Institute of Archaeology and Anthropology. It allows hand collection only, with no digging and no tools anywhere in state waters.
Local captain with LowCountry Coastal Excursions, running tours out of Shem Creek since 2017.